Home » Beauty Makeup Reviews » e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil, Review eyebrow pencil Buying Guide – Oemiu

e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil, Review eyebrow pencil Buying Guide – Oemiu

Oemiu September 5, 2025 Beauty Makeup Reviews

SaveSavedRemoved 0

Deal Score0

Deal Score0

e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil: A Detailed Review and Comprehensive Buying Guide for the Perfect Eyebrow Pencil

Eyebrows. They frame the face, express emotions, and when perfectly shaped, can make you look instantly more polished and put-together. In the vast world of makeup, achieving the perfect brow is a quest many embark on. But with so many eyebrow pencils, powders, gels, and pomades available, where do you even begin? This comprehensive guide will delve into the specifics of one popular and affordable option: the e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil, while also providing you with the essential knowledge to confidently choose the best eyebrow pencil for your individual needs and preferences.

e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil: A Closer Look

The e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil has garnered a considerable following, and for good reason. Its combination of affordability, availability, and decent performance makes it a strong contender in the drugstore makeup arena. But does it live up to the hype? Let’s break down its features, performance, and overall value.

Firstly, the packaging is simple and functional. The dual-ended pencil features a retractable, fine-tipped pencil on one end and a spoolie brush on the other. This is a common and convenient design for eyebrow pencils, allowing for both precise application and effortless blending. The retractable mechanism prevents product wastage and eliminates the need for sharpening, making it travel-friendly and easy to use on the go. The spoolie is a crucial component, helping to soften harsh lines, distribute product evenly, and groom the brows into the desired shape. Without a spoolie, achieving a natural-looking brow can be significantly more challenging.

The formula of the e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil is where opinions tend to diverge. It’s a wax-based formula, which offers decent hold and helps to keep the brows in place. The pigmentation is buildable, allowing you to create both natural and more defined looks. However, some users find the formula to be slightly dry or stiff, making it a bit difficult to achieve a seamless blend, especially if you have dry skin or sparse brows. Proper moisturization of the brow area before application can help mitigate this issue. Also, using a light hand during application is key to preventing a harsh or overly drawn-on appearance. Many users recommend short, feathery strokes to mimic natural brow hairs.

The shade range of the e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil is generally considered to be adequate, though not extensive. It typically includes shades ranging from light blonde to dark brown, catering to a relatively wide range of hair colors. However, individuals with very light or very dark hair may find it challenging to find a perfect match. It’s crucial to choose a shade that complements your natural hair color and skin tone. A shade that is too dark can look unnatural and harsh, while a shade that is too light may not provide enough definition. When in doubt, it’s often best to err on the side of a slightly lighter shade, as it’s easier to build up the intensity.

Longevity is another important factor to consider. The e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil typically lasts for a decent amount of time, generally around 6-8 hours, depending on your skin type and activities. Oily skin types may experience some fading or smudging throughout the day, particularly in humid conditions. Setting the brows with a brow gel or powder can help to extend the wear time and prevent smudging. For the price point, the longevity is reasonable, but those seeking all-day, waterproof wear may want to consider a higher-end option.

Here’s a quick summary of the pros and cons:

• Pros:
  • Affordable and widely available
  • Dual-ended design with spoolie brush
  • Retractable pencil – no sharpening required
  • Buildable pigmentation
  • Decent longevity for the price
• Cons:
  • Formula can be slightly dry or stiff
  • Limited shade range
  • May smudge on oily skin

Understanding Eyebrow Pencil Types and Formulas

The e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil is just one of many options available in the vast world of eyebrow enhancers. To make an informed decision, it’s essential to understand the different types of eyebrow pencils and their respective formulas. The best eyebrow filler truly depends on your individual brow concerns and desired results. Some need a super precise micro brow pencil for creating hair-like strokes, while others are happy with a wider pencil to fill in sparse areas quickly.

Pencil vs. Powder vs. Pomade vs. Gel:

While this guide focuses on eyebrow pencils, it’s important to briefly touch upon the other common types of brow products:

• Eyebrow Powders: Powders are great for creating a soft, natural look. They are best suited for filling in sparse areas and adding subtle definition. They are typically applied with an angled brush.
• Eyebrow Pomades: Pomades offer the most intense color payoff and longest wear time. They are ideal for creating bold, defined brows. However, they require more precision and skill to apply properly.
• Eyebrow Gels: Gels are primarily used to set the brows in place and add a touch of color or shine. They can be clear or tinted.

Types of Eyebrow Pencils:

• Retractable Pencils: These pencils are convenient and easy to use, as they don’t require sharpening. The e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil falls into this category.
• Traditional Pencils: These pencils need to be sharpened, which can be a bit more time-consuming. However, they often offer a wider range of formulas and tip sizes.
• Micro-Pencils: These pencils have extremely fine tips, allowing for precise application and the creation of hair-like strokes. They are ideal for filling in sparse areas and adding definition to the brow tail.
• Chubby Pencils: These pencils have thicker tips and are designed for quickly filling in the entire brow area. They are best suited for those with naturally full brows who just need a little bit of color and definition.

Formulas:

The formula of an eyebrow pencil can significantly impact its performance and the overall look of your brows. Here are some common formula types:

• Wax-Based Formulas: These formulas offer good hold and help to keep the brows in place. They are generally long-lasting but can sometimes be a bit dry or stiff.
• Powder-Based Formulas: These formulas create a soft, natural look. They are easy to blend but may not offer as much hold or longevity as wax-based formulas.
• Cream-Based Formulas: These formulas offer a good balance of pigmentation, blendability, and longevity. They are often moisturizing and comfortable to wear.

When choosing an eyebrow pencil, consider your desired look, brow type, and skin type. If you have sparse brows and want to create a natural-looking fill, a micro-pencil with a powder-based formula might be a good choice. If you have full brows and just want to add a little bit of definition, a chubby pencil with a wax-based formula might be a better option. And if you have oily skin, you’ll want to look for a long-lasting, smudge-proof formula.

Finding Your Perfect Shade: A Guide to Color Matching Your Eyebrow Pencil

Selecting the correct shade of eyebrow pencil is paramount to achieving a natural and flattering look. An ill-chosen shade can either make your brows look too harsh and unnatural or disappear altogether, defeating the purpose of enhancement. It is arguably even more important than the formula. You might adore the way a thin eyebrow pencil applies, but if the color is wrong, the outcome will be disappointing.

The Golden Rule: Match Your Hair Color (or Go Slightly Lighter)

The most fundamental principle is to match your eyebrow pencil shade to your natural hair color, or even opt for a shade slightly lighter. Going darker can often result in an overly dramatic and unnatural appearance, especially for those with lighter hair colors. A slightly lighter shade allows you to build up the intensity gradually and create a more subtle and refined look. If you have highlights or lowlights, consider matching the pencil to the base color of your hair.

Understanding Undertones

Just like foundation and concealer, eyebrow pencils also come in different undertones. Identifying your skin’s undertone (warm, cool, or neutral) can help you choose a shade that complements your complexion. Warm undertones typically have golden or yellow hues, cool undertones have pink or blue hues, and neutral undertones have a balance of both.

• Warm Undertones: If you have warm undertones, look for eyebrow pencils with warm brown or reddish-brown hues.
• Cool Undertones: If you have cool undertones, look for eyebrow pencils with cool brown or ash brown hues.
• Neutral Undertones: If you have neutral undertones, you can experiment with a wider range of shades, but generally, neutral brown shades work best.

Considering Your Hair Color

Here’s a general guideline for choosing eyebrow pencil shades based on hair color:

• Blonde Hair: Opt for light brown or taupe shades with cool undertones. Avoid shades that are too warm or golden, as they can look unnatural.
• Light Brown Hair: Choose medium brown shades with neutral or cool undertones.
• Medium Brown Hair: Select dark brown shades with neutral or warm undertones.
• Dark Brown Hair: Go for dark brown or black shades with cool or neutral undertones.
• Black Hair: Use black or dark brown shades with cool undertones.
• Red Hair: Look for auburn or reddish-brown shades with warm undertones.
• Gray Hair: Choose light gray or taupe shades with cool undertones.

Testing the Shade

The best way to find your perfect shade is to test it on your skin. Swatch a few different shades on your wrist or the back of your hand and see which one blends seamlessly with your natural skin tone. You can also try applying the pencil to your eyebrows and see how it looks in natural light. Remember to always test the shade in a well-lit area, as artificial lighting can distort the color.

Dealing with Sparse Brows

If you have sparse brows, you may want to choose a shade that is slightly darker than your natural hair color to add more definition and fullness. However, be careful not to go too dark, as this can make your brows look unnatural. Focus on filling in the sparse areas with short, feathery strokes to mimic natural brow hairs.

Remember, finding the perfect eyebrow pencil shade is a process of experimentation. Don’t be afraid to try different shades until you find one that you love. And don’t be afraid to mix and match shades to create a custom color that perfectly matches your hair and skin tone.

Application Techniques: Mastering the Art of Eyebrow Shaping

Even with the perfect eyebrow pencil and shade, the application technique can make or break your brow game. Mastering the art of eyebrow shaping requires practice and patience, but the results are well worth the effort. The goal is to create a natural-looking brow that complements your facial features and enhances your overall appearance. Whether you favor a mechanical eyebrow pencil or a traditional one, the approach remains consistent.

The Basic Steps:

1. Groom Your Brows: Start by grooming your brows with a spoolie brush to shape them and remove any stray hairs. Brush your brows upwards and outwards, following their natural arch.
2. Define the Shape: Use your eyebrow pencil to lightly outline the desired shape of your brows. Start with the lower edge, following your natural brow line. Then, define the upper edge, paying attention to the arch.
3. Fill in Sparse Areas: Fill in any sparse areas with short, feathery strokes, mimicking the direction of your natural brow hairs. Avoid creating solid lines, as this can look unnatural. Focus on building up the color gradually.
4. Blend and Soften: Use the spoolie brush to blend the pencil lines and soften the overall look. This will help to create a more natural and diffused appearance. Brush your brows upwards and outwards to distribute the product evenly.
5. Set Your Brows (Optional): If desired, you can set your brows with a brow gel to keep them in place and add a touch of shine. Clear brow gel is a great option for a natural look, while tinted brow gel can add more color and definition.

Techniques for Different Brow Types:

• Sparse Brows: If you have sparse brows, focus on filling in the gaps with short, feathery strokes. Use a micro-pencil or a fine-tipped pencil to create hair-like strokes. Pay attention to the arch and the tail of the brow, as these areas tend to be the sparsest.
• Full Brows: If you have full brows, you may only need to lightly fill in a few sparse areas or add a touch of definition to the arch. Use a light hand and avoid over-filling the brows, as this can make them look too heavy.
• Uneven Brows: If you have uneven brows, you can use your eyebrow pencil to create symmetry. Focus on shaping the thinner brow to match the fuller brow. Use short, feathery strokes to fill in any sparse areas and create a balanced look.
• Over-Plucked Brows: If you have over-plucked brows, you may need to reshape them using your eyebrow pencil. Start by defining the desired shape, then fill in the sparse areas with short, feathery strokes. Be patient and persistent, as it may take some time to regrow your brows.

Tips for a Natural Look:

• Use a Light Hand: Avoid applying too much pressure when using your eyebrow pencil. A light touch will help you create a more natural and diffused look.
• Follow the Direction of Your Hair Growth: Apply the pencil in the same direction as your natural brow hairs. This will help to blend the product seamlessly and create a natural-looking fill.
• Focus on the Arch and Tail: The arch and tail of the brow are the most important areas to define. These areas help to frame the face and create a lifted appearance.
• Blend, Blend, Blend: Blending is key to achieving a natural-looking brow. Use the spoolie brush to blend the pencil lines and soften the overall look.

Remember, practice makes perfect. Don’t be afraid to experiment with different techniques until you find one that works best for you. With a little bit of practice, you’ll be able to master the art of eyebrow shaping and create brows that perfectly complement your facial features.

Beyond the Pencil: Other Eyebrow Enhancement Options

While this guide focuses primarily on the use of eyebrow pencils, it’s important to acknowledge the existence and benefits of other eyebrow enhancement options. Different products cater to different needs and preferences, and exploring these alternatives can help you find the perfect solution for achieving your desired brow look. Sometimes a long lasting eyebrow pencil is not enough to get the desired results.

Eyebrow Powders:

Eyebrow powders offer a softer, more natural alternative to pencils. They are typically applied with an angled brush and are ideal for filling in sparse areas and adding subtle definition. Powders are particularly well-suited for those with oily skin, as they tend to absorb excess oil and prevent smudging. They are also a good option for beginners, as they are more forgiving than pencils and easier to blend.

Eyebrow Gels:

Eyebrow gels are primarily used to set the brows in place and add a touch of color or shine. They can be clear or tinted. Clear brow gels are perfect for grooming and shaping the brows without adding any color, while tinted brow gels can add more definition and fullness. Gels are a great option for those with naturally full brows who just need a little bit of hold and definition.

Eyebrow Pomades:

Eyebrow pomades offer the most intense color payoff and longest wear time. They are ideal for creating bold, defined brows. However, they require more precision and skill to apply properly. Pomades are typically applied with an angled brush and can be used to fill in sparse areas, define the arch, and create a dramatic brow look. They are a good option for those with sparse brows who want to create a fuller, more defined appearance.

Eyebrow Pens:

Eyebrow pens are similar to micro-pencils in that they have a very fine tip, allowing for precise application and the creation of hair-like strokes. They are ideal for filling in sparse areas and adding definition to the brow tail. Pens typically have a liquid or gel formula and offer long-lasting wear. They are a good option for those with sparse brows who want to create a natural-looking fill.

Microblading and Brow Tattooing:

For those seeking a more permanent solution to sparse or uneven brows, microblading and brow tattooing are options to consider. Microblading involves using a fine blade to create tiny incisions in the skin and deposit pigment into the brows. Brow tattooing uses a traditional tattoo machine to deposit pigment deeper into the skin. Both procedures can create a fuller, more defined brow look that lasts for several months or even years. However, they are relatively expensive and can be painful. It’s crucial to research and choose a reputable technician before undergoing either procedure.

Ultimately, the best eyebrow enhancement option depends on your individual needs, preferences, and budget. Experiment with different products and techniques until you find one that works best for you. Don’t be afraid to try something new and explore different options to achieve your desired brow look.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

How do I choose the right shade of eyebrow pencil for my hair color?

Selecting the right shade can be tricky, but there are a few key guidelines. The general rule of thumb is to match your eyebrow pencil to your hair color, or go slightly lighter. Going too dark can make your brows look harsh and unnatural, especially if you have lighter hair. Consider your undertones as well: if you have warm undertones, opt for warmer shades of brown. If you have cool undertones, look for cooler, ashier browns. For blondes, a light taupe or blonde shade usually works well. Brunettes can go for medium to dark brown shades, depending on the depth of their hair color. Redheads should consider auburn or reddish-brown shades. If you have gray hair, a light gray or taupe shade can look very natural. It’s always best to test the color on your skin before committing to a purchase, swatching it on your wrist or the back of your hand to see how it blends.

Is it better to use an eyebrow pencil or powder?

The choice between an eyebrow pencil and powder depends largely on your desired look and brow type. Eyebrow pencils are great for creating precise lines and defining the shape of your brows, particularly if you have sparse areas that need filling in. They’re also good for creating a more structured, defined brow look. On the other hand, eyebrow powders offer a softer, more natural finish. They’re ideal for filling in sparse areas without creating harsh lines and are particularly well-suited for those with oily skin, as the powder can help absorb excess oil. Ultimately, the best option depends on your personal preference and the look you’re trying to achieve. Some people even use a combination of both, using a pencil to define the shape and then filling in with powder for a softer finish.

How do I prevent my eyebrow pencil from smudging?

Smudging can be a common issue with eyebrow pencils, especially for those with oily skin. To prevent smudging, start by prepping your brows with a primer or a light layer of translucent powder. This will help to create a smooth, even surface for the pencil to adhere to and absorb any excess oil. When applying the pencil, use light, feathery strokes and avoid applying too much pressure. After filling in your brows, set them with a brow gel or a setting spray. Brow gel will help to keep the hairs in place and prevent the pencil from smudging, while setting spray will create a protective barrier over the brows. You can also try using a waterproof or smudge-proof eyebrow pencil for added security. Blotting your brows with a tissue throughout the day can also help to absorb any excess oil and prevent smudging.

What’s the best way to fill in sparse eyebrows with an eyebrow pencil?

Filling in sparse eyebrows requires a delicate touch to achieve a natural look. The key is to mimic the appearance of real brow hairs. Start by grooming your brows with a spoolie brush to shape them and identify the sparse areas. Then, using a fine-tipped eyebrow pencil, create short, feathery strokes in the direction of your natural hair growth. Focus on filling in the gaps between the existing hairs rather than drawing solid lines. Use a light hand and avoid applying too much pressure, as this can create a harsh, unnatural look. After filling in the sparse areas, blend the pencil with a spoolie brush to soften the lines and create a more diffused appearance. You can also use a brow powder to fill in the overall shape of the brow for a more natural finish. Remember to build up the color gradually, starting with a light layer and adding more as needed.

How do I create the perfect eyebrow arch with an eyebrow pencil?

Creating the perfect eyebrow arch can dramatically enhance your facial features and give you a more lifted, defined look. The ideal arch placement depends on your individual face shape. To find your natural arch, hold a pencil vertically against the side of your nose, aligning it with the outer edge of your iris. The point where the pencil intersects your brow is where your arch should ideally be. Using an eyebrow pencil, lightly define the lower edge of your brow, following your natural brow line. Then, define the upper edge, creating a gentle curve that peaks at the point you identified as your arch. Fill in any sparse areas with short, feathery strokes, paying particular attention to the arch itself. Blend the pencil with a spoolie brush to soften the lines and create a more natural appearance. Avoid creating a sharp, angular arch, as this can look unnatural and harsh. The goal is to create a subtle, natural-looking arch that complements your facial features.

Are expensive eyebrow pencils really worth the price?

Whether an expensive eyebrow pencil is worth the price depends on your individual needs and priorities. Higher-end eyebrow pencils often boast superior formulas, better pigmentation, and longer wear time compared to their drugstore counterparts. They may also offer a wider range of shades and a more precise application. However, many affordable eyebrow pencils on the market perform just as well, offering decent pigmentation, reasonable longevity, and a good selection of shades. Ultimately, the best way to determine if an expensive eyebrow pencil is worth the price is to try it out and compare it to a less expensive option. Consider factors such as formula, pigmentation, longevity, application, and shade range when making your decision. If you find that the expensive pencil offers a significant improvement in performance and meets your specific needs, then it may be worth the investment. However, if you’re happy with the performance of an affordable eyebrow pencil, there’s no need to spend more money.

Can I use an eyebrow pencil if I have microbladed eyebrows?

Yes, you can absolutely use an eyebrow pencil even if you have microbladed eyebrows. Microblading provides a base shape and color, but it may fade over time or require occasional touch-ups. An eyebrow pencil can be used to enhance the existing microblading, fill in any sparse areas that may have developed, or add definition to the arch or tail of the brow. When using an eyebrow pencil over microbladed brows, use a light hand and avoid applying too much pressure, as this can damage the microbladed pigment. Choose a shade that complements your microblading color and blend the pencil with a spoolie brush to create a seamless, natural look. Remember, the goal is to enhance the microblading, not to completely cover it up. An eyebrow pencil can also be used to experiment with different brow shapes and styles before committing to further microblading treatments.

Price: $4.00
(as of Sep 05, 2025 03:59:08 UTC – Details)